Winter 2020

From Darwin's Branched Tree to a Tangled Tree

Description

Darwin presented the evolution of life as branched like a tree. This idea has been upended by evolutionary biology through studying  life’s diversity and relatedness at the molecular level using DNA sequences. This reexamination of the history of all life has replaced Darwin's branching tree with a much more complex maze of branches.

In The Tangled Tree: A Radical New History of Life, David Quammen weaves together the stories of scientists and their genetic discoveries as they built a new view of the history of life that shows that DNA can be passed not between individuals but between species.

According to one reviewer, the book is “A masterful history of a new field of molecular biology . . . . [An] impressive account of perhaps the most unheralded scientific revolution of the 20th century. . . . A consistently engaging collection of vivid portraits of brilliant, driven, quarrelsome scientists in the process of dramatically altering the fundamentals of evolution, illuminated by the author's insightful commentary.” 

The book is well-written and the SDG should be a joy for those who are interested in new developments in evolutionary biology.

Weekly Topics

Week one- The Greeks and the beginning of Alchemy

Week two -The Dark Ages and Medieval times, Paracelsus

Week three - Copernicus, Bruno, Galileo, Descartes and Bacon

Week four - Boyle, Newton, Van Helmont, and Scheele

Week five - Phlogiston and the work of Becher, Stahl, Priestley, Cavendish and Lavoisier

Week six - Dalton and the Atom, Chemistry in the late 18th and early 19th Century

Week seven - Mendeleyev and the development of the PeriodicTable

Bibliography

Strathern, Paul, Mendeleyev's Dream:  The Quest for the Elements, Thomas Dunne Books, 2001 

Additional Reading

Scerri, Eric, The Periodic Table:  Its story and Its Significance, 2nd Edition, Oxford University Press, 2019

Leonardo at 500

Description

In the vast long history of “the arts”, one person stands out as the model of “The Renaissance Man”.  Leonardo da Vinci was a remarkable person of multiple interests and talents, as well as never ending ideas.  He was a sculptor, a painter, a scientist, a  designer of war machinery, a designer of fantastic celebrations, and a person who was always studying and recording his new ideas in journals which continue to amaze us. He was fascinated with the flight of birds, working toward the end goal of creating the possibility of flight for man. He was involved politically in the conflicts of his time, even as he created beautiful paintings and yet left other important commissions unfinished.      

At this point in human history, 500 years after his death, his art work and his ideas are still relevant and inspiring to us.

The Louvre museum in Paris, is a great repository of paintings and sculpture, where you will see a progression of wall signs and arrows directing you to arguably the world’s most famous painting:  Mona Lisa, a small painting by Leonardo. Arriving there you will see a huge crowd of people with their backs to the painting trying to take “selfies of themselves with the painting. However, in this SDG, you will learn that three other paintings by Leonardo, shown in the same room, are even more important than Mona Lisa. Be ready for an abundance of fascinating ideas as you study this intriguing man.

Weekly Topics

I THE BIRTH AND CHILDHOOD OF LEONARDO 1452-1464

II APPRENTICESHIP IN FLORENCE 1464-1482 AT THE WORKSHOP OF ANDREA DEL VERROCCHIO

III THE SFORZA COURT 1482-1499  SEVENTEEN YEARS IN MILAN

IV RETURN TO FLORENCE 1500-1506

V THE AFFAIRS OF WAR 1502-1506 SEERVICE TO CESARE BORGIA

VI RETURN TO MILAN 1506-1513

VII ROMAN HOLIDAY 1513-1516 THREE YEARS WITH GIOVANNI DE’ MEDICI

VIII IN THE FRENCH ROYAL COURT

IX AN OVERVIEW OF LEONARDO’S NOTEBOOK; A CLOSER STUDY OF HIS PAINTINGS

X COMPARING LEONARDO TO HIS CONTEMPONARIES.  

Bibliography

MAIN TEXT.   THE SDGWILL MOST CLOSELY FOLLOW THIS BOOK.

WALTER ISAACSON, LEONARDO DA VINCI. (Available in paperback $22.)

Supplemental Background Reading:

ROSS KING,

LEONARDO AND THE LAST SUPPER

GIORGIO VASARI,

THE LIVES OF THE MOST EXCELLEN PAINTERS, SCULPTORS AND ARCHITECTS

FRANK ZOLLNER,

LEONARDO DA VINCI: THE COMPLETE PAINTINGS

or other art brooks about Leonardo

TOBY LESTER,

DA VINCI’S GHOST: GENIUS, OBESSSION, AND HOW

LEONARDO CREATED THE WORLD IN HIS OWN IMAGE

JEAN-PIERRE ISBOUTS AND CHRISTOPHER HEATH BROWN, 

THE DA VINCI LEGACY

LAURO MARTINES, 

APRIL BLOOD, FLORENCE AND THE PLOT AGAINST THE MEDICI

STEPHANIE STOREY,

OIL AND MARBLE, A NOVEL OF LEONARDO AND MICHELANGELO

(light reading, but interesting as a picture of the times)

J. H. PLUMB

THE  ITALIAN RENAISSANCE

JOHN HOOPER

THE ITALIANS

TIM PARKS

MEDICI MONEY, BANKING, METAPHYSICS,  AND ART IN 15TH CENTURY FLORENCE 

WILLIAM E. WALLACE,

MICHELANGELO: THE ARTIST, THE MAN, AND HIS TIMES 

ROSS KING

MICHELANGELO AND THE POPE;S CEILING

BRUNELLESCHI’S DOME: HOW A RENAISSANCE GENIUS

REINVENTED ARCHITECTURE

Our Inner Ape

Description

This SDG takes its title from that of our core book by primatologist Frand de Waal.  This is science at its enjoyable best.  We learn about ourselves from looking in the mirror of our cousins’ eyes. De Waal writes about cooperation, conflict resolution, deception, altruism, fairness, and the evolutionary origins of morality.  He’s the director of the Yerkes National Primate Research Center at Emory University in Georgia.  He  has spent years observing and interacting on a daily basis with both bonobos and chimpanzees, our two closest relatives.  He provides us many anecdotes and insights from those years of personal involvement.

Weekly Topics

Week 1.  Apes in the Family   This topic will concern the evolutionary origins and relatedness of the different species of apes, including humans.  Behavior as well as physical characteristics are examined. 

 Week 2    Power     Dominance and submission and the formation of social  hierarchies are the topic.

 Week 3. Sex    Will look at the role of sex, not just for reproduction, but also  it’s roll in bonding and social hierarchies.

Week 4    Violence    This week will study the role of violence in primate societies.  Chimpanzees and bonobos are contrasted with each other and with humans. 

 Week 5.   Kindness     The role of kindness, empathy, and food sharing in  facilitating social bonding in  primate species and humans is the focus this week.

 Week 6    The Bipolar Ape    This chapter  title refers to humans and their innate bipolarity.  Humans are both aggressive and kind, prone to both fairness and deception.  The roots of human bipolarity are explored in an evolutionary context. 

 Week 7    This week we will explore how de Waal’s research and ideas have been accepted or rejected by others.  De Waal has been influential in his long career.  He has attacked the long prevalent view of humans as killer apes.  He nuances it, emphasizing both the  empathic and violent sides of our nature.  Other researchers readily adopt many of de Waal’s ideas and concepts. A case in point would be Steven Pinker. 

Bibliography

Our Inner Ape  by Franz de Waal, 2006

The Fight for the Soul of Quantum Physics

Description

When we hear the words "Quantum Physics" many of us I mmediately change the subject.  It just seems too obscure and difficult to comprehend. Yet, every day we rely on quantum physics for it allowed scientists to create what powers our world:  the silicon transistors and LEDs in you smartphones; nuclear reactors; the lasers that scan your food in the supermarket. Although you may not realize it, the development of quantum physics is one of science's greatest achievements and made our modern life possible. 

Most of us will never understand the mathematics that is foundation of quantum physics. If you ask a room full of physicists to explain quantum physics, you may start a street fight; even they find it confusing and weird. That does not meant that we aren't curious about it and interested in understanding it. 

Adam Becker gives us such an opportunity. His book, What is Real?: The Unfinished Quest For the Meaning of Quantum Physics, sketches the historical development of quantum mechanics and introduces us to the fascinating story of how physicists have tried (and fought with one another) to explain this area of physics. Perhaps the most famous brawl of all was the debate between Einstein and Bohr where Bohr's "Copenhagen interpretation" carried the day. That did not, however, silence the debate, and Becker introduces us to a fascinating cast of rebels who have dared to challenge the Copenhagen interpretation ever since. Becker places this story in the context the interactions between physics, politics, and culture throughout the 20th century. 

Becker's monograph is highly readable and accessible to scientists and non-scientists alike. He explains the concepts, including  Schrödinger’s infamous cat, that have divided physicists in understandable language that does not require familiarity with quantum physics.  This should be a fascinating SDG for PLATO members.

Weekly Topics

Week 1 - A Measure of All Things

Week 2 - Something Rotten in the Eigenstate of Denmark

Week 3 - Street Brawl

Week 4 - Copenhagen in Manhattan

Week 5 - Physics in Exile 

Week 6 - It Came from Another World 

Week 7 - The Most Profound Discovery of Science

Week 8 - More Things in Heaven and Earth 

Week 9 - Reality Underground

Week 10 - Quantum Spring

Week 11 - Copenhagen versus the Universe

Week 12 - Outrageous Fortune 

Bibliography

Adam Becker, What is Real?: The Unfinished Quest For the Meaning of Quantum Physics, 2018. 

The World is Getting Better: Factfulness and Enlightenment Now

Description

From watching, listening to, and reading about the daily news, it is easy to conclude that the world is going to hell in a handbasket.  But it isn’t.  The purpose of this S/DG is to show that the first part of its title, The World is Getting Better, is true by studying the information presented in the two books in the second part its title: Factfulness and Enlightenment Now.

The subtitle of Hans Rosling’s Factfulness is Ten Reasons We’re Wrong About the World—and Why Things Are Better Than You Think.  He calls the reasons Instincts that we all have and devotes a chapter to each.  The ten are The Gap Instinct, The Negativity Instinct, The Straight Line Instinct, The Fear Instinct, The Size Instinct, The Generalization Instinct, The Destiny Instinct, The Single Perspective Instinct, The Blame Instinct, and The Urgency Instinct.  In each chapter Rosling shows us how following that instinct can lead us to think incorrectly about the world, with many examples.  

As the title of the book implies, Rosling gives us facts that show us that we must put aside these instincts—and that we will then see that the world is indeed getting better.  In the chapter on The Negativity Instinct, for one, Rosling presents sixteen graphs on Bad Things Decreasing, including Children Dying, Plane Crash Deaths, and HIV Infections, as well as sixteen more on Good Things Increasing, including Girls in School, Immunization, and Democracy.

Rosling, working with his son, Ola Rosling, and his daughter-in-law, Anna Rosling Rönnlund, has developed unique ways of presenting data that make it easy for the reader to understand the essence of the numbers and ideas involved.

The subtitle of Steven Pinker’s Enlightenment Now is The Case for Reason, Science, Humanism, and Progress.  The new book is a logical continuation of his well-received 2011 book, The Better Angels of Our Nature.  

Enlightenment Now is divided into three unequal parts.  After a brief discussion on what Enlightenment is, the heart of the book is seventeen chapters on Progress in which Pinker shows, with great amounts of data displayed in dozens of charts and graphs along with extensive commentary, the gains that have been made over the years.  The titles of chapters five through sixteen are, Life, Health, Sustenance, Wealth, Inequality, The Environment, Peace, Safety, Terrorism, Democracy, Equal Rights, and Knowledge.

The book concludes with substantial chapters, separately, on Reason, Science, and Humanism.

Do not worry that books with such emphasis on facts will not give us ample basis for discussion.  Just looking at the chapter titles of each book should reassure you that we will have plenty to talk about.

The books are complementary.  Although they often present similar data and come to similar conclusions, the commentary and methods of display are so different that you will find both valuable.

Both books were published in 2018, ensuring that the data they present are up to date.  Together the two books are about seven hundred pages.

About The Better Angels of Our Nature, Bill Gates said, “One of the most important books I’ve read—not just this year, but ever.”  He has topped that assessment with what he says about Enlightenment Now, calling it, “My new favorite book of all time.”  And he likes Factfulness just about as well, calling it, “One of the most important books I’ve ever read—an indispensable guide to thinking clearly about the world.”

Weekly Topics

The first five weeks are from Factfulness.
1.  Introduction and Chapter 1
2.  Chapters 2 and 3
3.  Chapters 4 and 5
4.  Chapters 6, 7, and 8
5.  Chapters 9, 10, and 11.

The final nine weeks are from Enlightenment Now.
6.  Chapters 1 through 4
7.  Chapters 5 through 8
8.  Chapters 9 and 10
9.  Chapters 11, 12, and 13
10.  Chapters 14, 15, and 16
11.  Chapters 17 and 18
12.  Chapters 19 and 20
13.  Chapters 21 and 22
14.  Chapter 23.

Bibliography

Factfulness.  Hans Rosling with Ola Rosling and Anna Rosling Ronnlund.  2018

Enlightment Now.  Steven Pinker.  2018.

Spooks - National Security and the History of the CIA

Description

The CIA is known for secret assassinations, thrilling spy encounters and international blunders.   This course looks at the history of the CIA, beginning with the OSS in WWII to recent involvement in the execution of foreign policy through covert operations.  The subject matter will be a world tour of foreign policy though the last 70 years. We will attempt to understand how this agency has shaped not only American diplomacy, but the perception of America throughout the world.  Current opinion polls show that a majority of Americans view the CIA favorably, but have significant concerns with respect to the CIA and privacy and the CIA and civil liberties.  How do we balance democracy with unseen government intervention?  There is a rich assortment of reading materials that invite serious discussions about spying, covert actions, and if a secret bureaucracy is needed to preserve American freedoms.  

Weekly Topics

1.    Spies and Secrecy;  WWII, Roosevelt and the OSS, and Wild Bill Donovan

2.    CIA Beginnings:  Truman, George Kennon and Allen Dulles

3.    The Iran Coup (1953)

4.    South America and the Guatemala Coup (1954) 

5.    The Bay of Pigs, anti-Castro operations and the Cuban Missile Crises  (1962)

6.    The CIA and the Vietnam War, and consequences for U. S. Intelligence

7.    Nixon, the Coup in Chili (1973) and Watergate (1974)

8.    Iran Hostage Crises (1979-81) and the Iran-Contra Affair (1985)

9.    The Berlin Wall and the collapse of the Soviet Union (1991)

10   The CIA and the Modern Middle East (1947 Syria, 1988 Iran-Iraq War, 2003 Iraq)

11.  The CIA and the 911 Attack (2001), Iraq, Bin Laden and Afghanistan

12.  Snowden (2013) Russian cyber hacks (2016) and foreign influence on US politics 

13.   Technology, Drones and Cybersecurity

14.   Cyber weapons, Space, and the future of espionage

Bibliography

Recommended Books:

Andrew, C. (1995),  For the President's Eyes Only:  Secret Intelligence and the American Presidency.

Immerman, R. (2014) The Hidden Hand, A brief history of the CIA.

Morley, J. (2008).  Our Man in Mexico:  Winston Scott and the Hidden History of the CIA.

Prados, J. (2006).  Safe for Democracy:  The Secret Wars of the CIA. *

Wallace, R. & Melton, K. (2008).  Spycraft:  The Secret History of the CIA's Spytechs from Communism to Al-Qaeda.

Wilford, H. (2019).  The Agency:  A History of the CIA (the Great Courses - video and audible (audible.com). *

Wilford, H. (2013),  America's Great Game:  The CIA's Secret Arabists and the Shaping of the Modern Middle East.

*  Best for general information

Election 2020

Description

Every four years our nation goes through a political paroxysm of (pick one):  furious activity, anxiety, fear, or loathing.  The Presidential election -- this year may be the worst ever.  The nation has gone through a grueling time since the 2016 election.   Now, not only must we choose our president & vice-president, 1/3 of all Senators, all members of the House of Representatives, countless governors and state legislators – we are faced with two very different philosophies of governance. 

This SDG proposes to study Election 2020 in each of the three terms in 2020.  While we will focus on the Presidential race, we’ll also discuss important local and national trends & issues as they emerge.

During the course of the year, we'll cover:  election funding; PACs and SUPER PACs; how to win friends & votes:  advertising/PR/events; endorsements & what they mean; analyses of all debates; media coverage – fair and balanced, or…; geographical differences; polls & pollsters; real issues and phony issues; friends and foes; is honesty the best policy?; how do politicians approach/avoid talking about issues, and any and all relevant news.

Election 2020 #2 – Spring/Summer

By this point, the Presidential field is pretty narrow.  Competition for the Vice-Presidential slot is increasing.  Primaries are over, and platform discussions begin.  And then… conventions.

 Election 2020 #3 – Fall 

We will discuss how the campaigns are faring… and then, after the results are in, we’ll analyze them.

Note:  Since committing to a year-long course may be difficult or impractical, persons will initially sign up for Winter Term.  Those who wish to stay in the course will have priority for the nest term(s).  Open spaces will be filled at registration.

Weekly Topics

During the Winter term, when there will be a lot of Democratic candidates (and maybe even a Republican candidate or two), each member of the SDG will pick one Presidential candidate and spend the first hour of the SDG discussing that candidate. Then in the next hour, the same member will discuss one of these (or other relevant) topics:

  • The current atmosphere -- what’s gone on since 2016

  • The candidates

  • The hottest issues - they might even change week to week

  • Whistleblowers

  • Impeachment

  • Foreign commitments

  • The Electoral College v popular vote

  • Money, money, money

  • The primary/caucus process/Iowa

  • Diversity v identity politics

  • Voter suppression v voter fraud

  • The California primary -- and of course we'll follow the others

  • Social media

  • Polls

  • 24-hour news cycles

  • Debates

  • Fake news

  • Trolls/foreign intervention

  • Blue, red & purple states

  • Regulation v deregulation

  • Congress

  • Tariffs

  • Immigration

  • Emergency declarations

  • Presidential power

  • Emoluments

  • And more, lots more 

Bibliography

Any & all news media

The Female Gaze: Woman Filmmakers

Description

This SDG examines eleven exceptional films made by women filmmakers around the world that offer a variety of themes: gender, class, race, globalization, the family, coming-of-age, religion, capitalism, and art.  Genres include comedy, drama, horror, thriller, western, and documentary..

The directors, from seven countries and cultures, bring personal styles and insights to their work, and feature both male and female protagonists.  One of the questions we'll ask is about the differences brought to their films by nationality and race.  And what might a woman bring to films that a male filmmaker might miss?   And does a woman necessarily brings a feminist or political vision to a film? Finally, is there "a female gaze?"

This is a Film Studies course with emphasis on film analysis.  We are interested in how how the art of film--narrative, mise en scene, cinematography, music, sound, editing, acting, expresses each director's unique vision.

Participants should be very comfortable using computers and DVDs. 

Weekly Topics

  1. My Brilliant Career, Gillian Armstrong - Australia  1979

  2. The Piano, Jane Campion - Australia  1993

  3. The Holy Girl, Lucretia Martel - Argentina  2004

  4. After the Wedding, Suzanne Bier - Denmark  2006

  5. 35 Shots of Rum, Clair Denis - France  2008    

  6. Winter's Bone, Debra Granek - United States  2010

  7. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night, Ana Lily Amirpour - Iran/United States   2014

  8. Toni Erdmann, Maren Ade - Germany  2016

  9. Certain Women, Kelly Reichardt - United States  2016 

  10. The Gleaners; Faces/Places, Agnes Varda - France  2000; 2017

  11. The Rider, Chloe Zhao - United States  2017

Participants will choose their week and film in any order.  

Bibliography

Core Book:

Louis Gannett, Understanding Movies, Prentice Hall.  Buy a used edition, any edition.

All of the films are available on Netflix DVDs as well as other streaming channels.  Reviews and articles on all the filmmakers and films can be found on the Internet.  

An extended bibliography will be given to participants.

Can You Dig It? The Story of Archaeology

Description

Ever since my future mother in law gave me a special gift, I have been fascinated with Archaeology, including the gift,  the famous book by C.W. Ceram, Gods, Graves, and Scholars.  Yes, I am an Indiana Jones fan through and through,  It is such a thrill to read about Lord Carnarvon and Howard Carter unearthing the ruins of King Tut's tomb.  Also, I am intrigued with the lost cities of the Olmec, Aztecs, Incas and Mayans.  It is a special privilege to view the cable show, Expedition Unknown, and experience the Smithsonian and National Geographic as well as the Nova offerings on Archaeology.  Over the years I am joined (in spirit) with the expeditions to find Nifertiti and Cleopatra tombs.  Two of my favorite archaeologists and finders remain Schliemann and Elgin as well as the Leakeys.  Their personalities left something to be desired, but they were men and women who preserved the past and presented to the world their findings.  As an armchair archaeologist I have collected museum and excavation boardgames that have brought to life Mesopotamia, the Middle East, Far China, Atlantis, Teotihuacan,  Machu Picchu and Cuzco.  Two of my favorite "digging" films are Journey to the Center of the Earth and The Mummy (various versions) that have archaeological implications.  What can we learn from Archaeology much more than digging up the past, scraping shards of dirt, or brushing an unearthed statue?  It is a rewarding study of how scientists, fortune hunters, and collectors go to the ends of the Earth to find what other civilizations were like.  Their unearthing, as tiresome and tedious as it may be, reveals worlds we thought could never be brought back to life. 

Weekly Topics

Session 1.  Theory & Methods of Archaeology:  Lessons from King Tut's Tomb

Definitions of Archaeology:  The Passive to Rubbish.  Archaeology and Storytellers.  "The Wondrous Things."  

Session 2.  Ashes to Ashes in Ancient Italy:  What Pompeii and Herculaneum Meant.

Session 3.  Digging Up Troy:  Did It Exist?

Session 4.  From Egypt to Eternity:  Are You an Egyptologist?

Session 5.  Mysteries in Mesopotamia:  Were the Babylon Gardens Found?  

Session 6.  Discovering our Earliest Ancestors, First Farmers in the Fertile Crescent:  Pre-Historic Africa

Session 7.  Exploring the Jungles of Central America and Mexico:  Tikal, Palenque, Uxmal, Copán, Teotihuacán

Session 8.  Revealing the First Greeks:  the Bronze Age

Session 9.  Classical Greece:  Discus Throwing to Democracy

Session 10.  Finding Atlantis?:  Did It Exist?  Was it Santorini or Akrotiri?

Session 11.  The Roman Eras:  What did the Romans teach us about preservation?

Session 12.  Cities of the Desert:  Excavating Armageddon, Petra

Session 13.  Unearthing the Bible:  What Really Happened at Masada?

Session 14.  Session 14.  Do you keep what you find?:  Museum Collections, Looting, New Advances with LiDAR and Other Technologies, Excavations (e.g.  Submarine Hunley) and UNESCO Sites

Bibliography

Core Book

Cline, Eric H.  Three Stones Create a Wall:  The Story of Archaeology.  Princeton, New Jersey:  Princeton University Press, 2017.

Selected Bibliography

Bahn, Paul, ed.  The History of Archaeology:  An Introduction.  London and New York:  Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2014.

Carlsen, William.  Jungle of Stone:  The True Story of Two Men, Their Extraordinary Journey and The Discovery of the Lost Civilization of          The Maya.  New York:  HarperCollins, 2016.

Ceram, C.W.  Gods, Graves, & Scholars--The Story of Archaeology.  Second, Revised, and Substantially Enlarged Edition.  

    Cambridge and New York:   Alfred A. Knopf, 1968.

Down, David.  The Archaeological Book.  Green Forest, Arkansas.:  MasterBooks, 2010.  

Fagan, Brian A.  Eyewitness to Discovery:  First-Person Accounts of More Than Fifty of the World's Greatest Archaeological Discoveries.           New York:  Oxford University Press, 1996.  

_________.  Writing Archaeology:  Telling Stories about the Past.  Walnut Creek, California:  Left Coast Press, Inc. 2006.  

Magness, Jodi.  The Archaeology of the Holy Land:  from the Destruction of Solomon's Temple to the Moslem Conquest.  Cambridge and          New York:  Cambridge University Press, 2012.  

Parcak, Sarah.  Archaeology from Space:  How the Future Shapes Our Past.  New York:  Henry Holt and Company, 2019.

White, Nancy Marie.  Archaeology for Dummies.  Hoboken, New Jersey:  Wiley Publishing, Inc., 2008.